Monetizing the housing debt
 Submitted By Tim Iacono
In reading the newspapers over the last eight months, since the Federal Reserve decided to print money on a massive scale in order to buy $300 billion in U.S. Treasuries along with about a trillion and a half dollars in mortgage related debt, these two groups of purchases have been viewed quite differently.
The former is seen as a particularly bad thing for a central bank to be doing as this money created "out of thin air" is used to directly fund government spending, spurring comparisons to Zimbabwe and Weimar Germany where similar efforts led to hyper-inflation.
 However, the latter is viewed as something of a benign undertaking (by comparison, at least), widely perceived as providing needed support for housing in the U.S. by creating a market for housing debt that might not otherwise exist.
After all, would you buy 2003-2008 vintage mortgages that have been "securitized" by Wall Street firms or one of the two wards of the state - Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac - if the Fed wasn't buying the stuff too?
I wouldn't.
Is there really that big of a difference between these two?
Since the U.S. government and their "too big to fail" banking friends now essentially own the entire domestic mortgage market (causing understandable confusion as to which way the arrow would be pointing on a hypothetical org chart that included the U.S. government and "quasi-government" organizations like Citibank and Bank of America) is there really that much of a distinction between U.S. debt and U.S. housing debt?
By buying all this stuff, isn't the central bank effectively monetizing the housing debt?
And shouldn't a lot more people (particularly in China and Japan) be concerned?
As shown below in the now familiar depiction of the Federal Reserve's balance sheet, since the financial crisis has ebbed and banks are able to pay back some of the money they had to borrow when it looked like the entire world was going to implode, the only items that continue to grow are U.S. Treasuries, mortgage-backed securities (MBSes), and agency debt in the form of loans to Fannie and Freddie.
 Clearly, there are big differences between U.S. debt and these two forms of housing debt.
For example, when the government sells Treasuries to the central bank in exchange for newly printed money, it does so with the tacit understanding that the money will never have to be paid back.
But, when the Fed does the same thing in exchange for Fannie and Freddie bonds, then...
Well, actually, these two appear to be one and the same. The GSEs are fundamentally bankrupt, a characterization that, save for its ability to borrow and print money, applies to the U.S. government as well, and there would seem to be little chance of all the GSE bonds owned by the Fed being redeemed at full value unless the government steps in with borrowed money or, in the oddest of all circuitous monetary routes, with money it received from the central bank itself.
However, there is a distinction between U.S. debt and mortgage backed securities. In the case of the latter, newly created money is paid to whoever used to own the securitized loan - Fannie, Freddie, Citibank, Bank of America, etc. - and then, in theory at least, the central bank sees returns based on homeowners making their mortgage payments.
The only thing is, more and more homeowners are no longer able to make their payments and, as a result, the value of these securities would have tumbled to unknown depths if not for the central bank coming to the rescue and paying what others won't.
What is the true value of these mortgage backed securities?
In theory, we'll find out early next year when the Fed stops buying them, but, like the homebuyer tax credit, don't be surprised if this wildly popular program is extended, perhaps indefinitely as waves of foreclosures come ashore in 2010 and 2011.
Perhaps it would help to consider the similarities between the Fed using its printing press to buy Treasuries and to buy MBSes.
On the one hand, you have a government that got itself into a jam by spending more money than it could bring in or borrow at low interest rates, so the central bank had to print up money to make up the difference, trading newly created U.S. dollars for U.S. Treasuries.
On the other hand, you have a housing market that got itself into a jam, enabled by the 30-year government drive for higher rates of homeownership which was financed by the government sponsored owned mortgage giants and banks now deemed too big to fail, all of this culminating in one more in a long series of bursting asset bubbles that appears to be business as usual in recent decades for the U.S. economy.
That the Federal Reserve has to print money "out of thin air" to buy $1 trillion or so of this souring mortgage debt shouldn't come as too big of a surprise.
In both cases it's a matter of throwing good money after bad, the odds of the Federal Reserve getting anywhere near what it paid for these MBSes (if and when it ever goes to sell them) being about as good as the odds of the U.S. government running a sufficient surplus to pay back any of the $300 billion that was given to it by the central bank.
The system wasn't set up to work this way.
If the founding fathers knew that we had created yet another central bank and, not only was it printing up money to fund government spending but it was buying up home loans, they'd roll over in their graves (except maybe for Alexander Hamilton).
Since its founding almost a hundred years ago, the central bank has, for the most part, done its job simply by buying and selling treasuries, a fact that is clear to see in recent data below.
 But, over the last year or so, there's been a radical change in what the central bank buys with money it creates with a simple keystroke and, now that housing and government activities have been so intertwined, is there any real difference between the U.S. government's finances and the finances of the nation's housing market.
It's one thing to step in and provide support for commercial paper markets and money markets, but it's quite another to step in and support the housing market that is now almost wholly owned by the U.S. government in one way or another.
You don't just "unwind" this kind of support.
Of course, if home prices zoom back to their 2005-2006 highs, it's quite possible that the GSEs will spring back to life despite being in the hole by over $100 billion with the red ink still flowing freely. In this case, the Fed could probably sell all its MBSes back into the market and all would be square.
But, that seems about as likely as the U.S. government running a surplus.
If the mortgage backed securities do get sold back into the market in the coming years at anywhere near the price the Fed paid, then all we'll have succeeded in doing is re-inflating the housing bubble, which, come to think of it, is probably the current plan.
But, more likely than not, all this new money that has and will continue to be conjured into existence to buy bad assets - be they U.S. treasuries, bonds issued by Fannie and Freddie, or home loans made against overpriced houses - will all just make the rest of the U.S. money currently in existence less valuable simply because there is more of it.
Maybe a lot less valuable.
 
Did you like this article?
|
Recommended Online Finance Courses
|
$5000 Practice Forex Trading Account
Software and live rates provided by FXCM
|
's
The newest version of cheap
To establish a new effective
DeWitt replica ebel
ebel replica
Ferrari replica
Franck Muller replica
Glashutte replica
Graham replica
Hermes replica
Hublot replica
IWC replica
Jaquet droz replica
Lady replica
Longines replica
Louis Vuitton replica
Maurice Lacroix replica
Montblanc replica
movado replica
omega replica
oris replica
Panerai replica
gift. replica watches uk
replica watches uk
But what can youFake rolex
bring? It can bereplica watch Longines
difficult to figure out what kind of a gift to bring sometimes, especiallyChopard Watches replica watches
when you are tryingreplica watches
to purchase a giftBest Replica watches
that is inexpensive, useful, and that your gift recipientreplica handbags Thomas Wylde Studded Skull Bag Black for sale
will like. Instead ofcheap Giverchy for sale
looking towards the samereplica-Purses-outlet
old gifts, like house sculptures and other homereplica bag
accessories, take a lookGucci Large Tote in Gold canvass
at Replica Watches .Fendi large bag-black leather F2582-04
The watches that are being made now is not the sameNew Replica Tiffany & Co Bracelets tjewelrybracelet194
kind of Replica VacheronNew Replica Gucci G charm necklace
Constantin that your parentsNew Replica Gucci Jewelry gjewelry0831119
or grandparents used to buy. These replica watchesOmega watches
are made using thewatches replica
same high quality materialscheap Omega Seamaster 007 OMEG-18-626 watch replica
that the originals are made out of. They aWe can supply you discount
شات رجاوي شات
Here are cheap north face
Here are cheap north face outlets, these northface jacket clothes are designed with a waterproof, breathable, fully seam sealed exterior shell and a removable, insulated interior, cheap northface from our cheap northface jacket online sale.-zouzhilong007
NBA Basketball
NBA Basketball Shoes
Nbasupplier.com are authentic NBA Basketball Shoes supplier, who have a long history in NBA basketball shoes trade. Their customers are from all over the world. The best quality and best service promise to you. You can find the newest and the classic style in this online store. Shop for NBA Signature Basketball Shoes from atasale.com. You can find pages with details of the NBA players that wear these brands and wich model of shoe they wear.
This New Allen Iverson Shoes : Reebok Answer XII Invictus shoes will be printed in the history. Allen Iverson is a great scorer that will have a place in the House of Fame. His sneaker has a fabulous history. If you are Crazy about Kobe Bryant Shoes, there are Nike Zoom Kobe Shoes Mens and Womens Collection for you. Or Lebron James is your idol aslo can collect all his Signature Shoes there.
The eastern part of the all star line-ups list: Dwight Howard, LeBron James Shoes, Kevin Garnett, Dwyane Wade, Allen Iverson; West all star line-ups list: Kobe Bryant, Yao Ming, Tim Duncan Shoes, Chris-Paul, Amare Stoudemire. And as we know, there are so many fans, men even women, are bound up in NBA. Atasale.com, he can support you the NBA Shoes about those NBA MVP. /You xiaoyan
replica Jaquet droz replica
replica Lady Watch
replica Longines
replica Louis Vuitton
replica Maurice Lacroix
replica Montblanc
replica movado
replica omega
replica oris
replica Panerai
replica Patek Philippe
watches for salecroum
croum watches
Panerai watches
omega watch for sale
Rado replica
replica omega
replica Franck Muller
Rolex Milgauss watch for sale
Montblanc watches
fake Tiffany jewelrycheap
cheap Christian louboutin
replica Montega watches
replica carlfbucherer watches
fake versace watches
replica watches
excellent quality replica swiss watches
discount Christian
replica bottega veneta
discount skagen watches
cheap citizen watches
discount jaegerlecoultre watches
replica watchesreplica
replica watch
Louis Vuitton watches
replica Tudor watches
replica Rolex Yachtmaster watches
watches for salereplica
replica watch
movado watch for sale
Tag Heuer replica
Franck Muller watches
ebel replica
automatic watches
cheap replica watchesreplica
replica watch
watches replica
Rado watches
Bvlgari watch for sale
Rolex Explorer watches
replica Audemars Piguet watches
Rolex Submariner watches
replica Breguet
Watch Accessories for sale
replica Rolex Air King
breitling swiss replica watches
replica watchreplica Franck
replica Franck Muller
Lady replica
replica Rolex Milgauss
Rolex Explorer replica
A.Lange & Sohne watches
movado watches
Glashutte watches
replica Rolex Day-Date II
Audemars Piguet replica
cheap fake
Yachtmaster watch for sale
replica Franck Muller
Rolex Daytona watches
Concord watches
Cartier watches
replica Rolex Sea-Dweller
watches replicareplica
replica watch
Patek Philippe watches
Bell & Ross watch for sale
Rolex Milgauss replica
Rolex Masterpiece replica
iPod to PC， iPhone to
Rolex Daydate Automatic with
cheap fake watchesreplica
replica watches
Hublot watches
Piaget watch for sale
Rolex Submariner watch for sale
Breguet replica
Glashutte watches
we know winter is very
replica watchesRolex Day
Rolex Day Date watch for sale
replica Rolex Explorer
Rolex Milgauss watches
replica Rolex Daytona
replica Longines
replica Rolex Yachtmaster
replica Cartier
Breguet watches replica
Ugg Boots Sale -Famous top
三體牛鞭 三體牛鞭
三體牛鞭
三體牛鞭
韩国留学
美国留学
美国留学中介
澳洲留学
澳大利亚留学
留学澳洲
留学澳大利亚
视频会议软件
网络视频会议
软件视频会议
全向麦克风
全向麦克
电话会议
音频会议
会议电话
电话会议系统
电话会议终端
回音消除
回声消除
回音抑制
多方通话
多方通话
电话会议系统
电话会议服务
电话会议平台
多方电话会议
视频会议软件
网络视频会议
软件视频会议
音频会议
电话会议
会议电话
电话会议系统
电话会议终端
全向麦克风
全向麦克
宝利通会议电话
polycom会议电话
网络多方会议
网络视频会议
软件视频会议
网络视频会议解决方案
视频会议软件
全向麦克风
麦克风
全向麦克
回音消除麦克风
会议室
多媒体会议室
电子会议室
会议室集成
数字多媒体会议室
电子会议室解决方案
多功能厅系统集成
视频会议室集成
多功能会议厅
电子多媒体会议室
数字音频处理器
Polycom代理
会议电话
会议电话机
会议电话终端
音频会议
电话会议
电话会议系统
电话会议解决方案
电话会议平台
多方电话会议系统
多方通话
多方会议
多方音频会议
视频会议
电话会议平台
多方电话会议系统
多方通话
多方会议
多方音频会议
电话会议
音频会议
网络视频会议
网络多方会议
软件视频会议
视频会议软件
全向麦克风
全向麦克
麦克风
会议电话
会议电话机
电话会议系统
电子多媒体会议室
电子会议室
多媒体会议室
会议室
视频会议室集成
会议室集成
多功能会议厅
数字多媒体会议室
上海会议电话
深圳会议电话
北京会议电话
reelight
freelights
bike lights
bicycle light
ClearOne
chat50
chat150
psr1212
xap400
xap800
converge 560
converge 590
AccuMic
rav600
rav900
clearone 840T
clearone 880T
sr1212
clearone th2
clearone th20
PRO 840T
PRO 880T
soundstation2
clearone chat 150
Clearone chat 50
soundstation 2 标准型
soundstation 2 基本型
Soundstation 2 扩展型
视频采集卡
osprey 视频采集卡
osprey 210 视频采集卡
osprey 50 视频采集卡
osprey 230 视频采集卡
sony d70 网络摄像机
sony d100 网络摄像机
sony d70 摄像头
sony d100 摄像头
三體牛鞭
撃天柱カプセル
TAFE
澳大利亚留学费用
澳洲大学申请
澳大利亚大学排名
澳大利亚大学
澳大利亚留学咨询
7天
澳洲留学贷款
阿德雷德大学
礼仪培训师
如家
如家
格林豪泰
格林豪泰
成都欧亚男科医院
陕西省皮肤病性病防治所
陕西省皮肤病性病防治所
澳大利亚留学中介
澳洲留学中介
澳大利亚留学硕士
澳大利亚研究生
澳洲研究生
澳大利亚TAFE
澳大利亚TAFE专业
澳洲TAFE课程
澳洲签证
澳大利亚签证
澳大利亚留学条件
留学澳大利亚手续
澳洲留学生活
澳洲留学贷款
澳大利亚奖学金
澳洲奖学金
莫纳什大学
墨尔本大学
悉尼大学
澳洲国立大学
昆士兰大学
新南威尔士大学
阿德雷德大学
西澳大学
7天
7天
锦江之星
锦江之星
格林豪泰
格林豪泰
上海锦江之星
莫泰168
莫泰168
汉庭
如家快捷酒店
锦江之星酒店
汉庭
汉庭
礼仪培训
速8
速8
速8
锦江之星酒店
布丁酒店
桔子酒店
桔子酒店
机票
特价机票
打折机票
飞机票
折扣机票
机票查询
机票预订
国际机票
国际机票查询
国际机票打折
特价国际机票
北京国际机票
机票价格查询
日文SEO
日文SEO
日本网站推广
日本网站推广
日本网站推广
日文网站推广
日文网站推广
日文网站推广
日文网站推广
日文网站推广
日文网站推广
日语网站推广
日语网站推广
日语网站推广
日语网站推广
日语网站推广
日语网站优化
日语网站优化
日语网站优化
日语网站优化
日语网站优化
日文网站优化
日文网站优化
日文网站优化
日文网站优化
日文网站优化
日本网站优化
日本网站优化
日本网站优化
日本网站优化
日文SEO
日文SEO
日文SEO
日文SEO
日文SEO
日语SEO
日语SEO
日语SEO
日语SEO
日语SEO
日语google推广
日语google推广
日语google推广
日语google推广
日语google推广
日语google推广
日语google推广
日本google推广
日本google推广
日本google推广
日本google推广
日本google推广
日文google推广
日文google推广
日文google推广
日文google推广
日文google推广
日文google推广
日文google推广
日文雅虎推广
日文雅虎推广
日文雅虎推广
日文雅虎推广
日文雅虎推广
日文雅虎推广
日语雅虎推广
日语雅虎推广
日语雅虎推广
日语雅虎推广
日语雅虎推广
日语雅虎推广
日本雅虎推广
日本雅虎推广
日本雅虎推广
日本雅虎推广
日本雅虎推广
留学
留学
留学
留学
留学
留学
留学
留学
留学
留学
留学
留学
留学
留学
留学
留学
留学
留学
留学
留学
留学
留学
The immediate reaction by
Thank you for your
Adidas 35TH
Cheap Chanel Quilted UGG
|bags for a year now|to rock
Cheap louis vuitton sale
replica watchesreplica
replica watch
U-boat watch for sale
replica Rolex Day Date
Rolex Explorer watch for sale
Jaquet droz replica
replica LV handbags
replica Cartier watches
We guarantee we provide the
We guarantee we provide the cheapest ghd, ghd Hair Straighteners,ghd straighteners, ghd hair tools in the market and 100% Quality Guarantee.
discount Christian
cheap Jimmy Choo Shoes
Christian Louboutin sandal on sale
discount Jimmy Choo Shoes
discount Christian Louboutin Pump
Tiffany heart tag ring Flower ring
It is a wonderful
This FLV Converter is a fast
I love ugg boots sale ，
cardy ugg boots ， UGG Classic Mini ， Classic Cardy Uggs ，
Nightfall UGG Boots ， Classic Tall UGGs ， Classic Short UGGs ，
Sundance UGGs Boots。
Tiffany Jewellery handles
I would like to buy ugg
Thank you for your info